From Staff
Census data shows the state's growth comes from the Northeast, not its neighbors and the cheapest market in the state is slow for a reason.
South Carolina grew faster than any other state in the country last year. It also lost a great many of the people it gained. The two facts are not in tension. They are the same fact, read from opposite directions.
The Census Bureau's American Community Survey recorded roughly 189,600 people moving into South Carolina from another state in 2024 while about 134,800 moved out. The net gain of about 54,800 ranked fifth in the nation, behind Texas, Florida, North Carolina and Arizona. State population estimates put South Carolina at 5,570,274 as of July 2025, an increase of 79,958, or 1.5 percent, the fastest percentage growth of any state.
That headline conceals a market that is mostly churn. About 324,000 gross moves touched the state line to produce a net gain of 54,800. Roughly five of every six people who arrived were offset by someone leaving.
North Carolina sent about 33,200 people and took about 30,000 back. Georgia sent 16,000 and received 16,900. Virginia sent 8,600 and received 12,700, the largest net loss to any single state. Texas and South Carolina swapped a combined 16,270 residents for a net difference of 50 people.
The Census Bureau attaches a margin of error of roughly 5,000 people to each of those flow estimates. That matters more than it sounds. Every net figure below roughly 7,000 in the state by state table is statistically indistinguishable from zero, which includes North Carolina, New Jersey, Ohio, Georgia and Texas. The two Carolina’s did not trade residents at a slight advantage. They traded them at a draw.
The reason is geography rather than preference. The Charlotte metropolitan area crosses into York and Lancaster counties, where Fort Mill, Tega Cay, Rock Hill and Indian Land function as suburbs of a city in another state. Aiken and North Augusta sit across the Savannah River from Augusta. Hardeeville and the rest of Jasper County are the back yard of Savannah. Jasper added about 1,400 housing units between mid 2024 and mid 2025, a jump of 8.3 percent. The county's population grew 6 percent, the fastest rate in the country. Hardeeville alone expanded by roughly 16 percent.
Families relocating within those border metros keep their employers, their churches and their commutes. The only thing that changes is the line on the map and the name on the license. The Census counts it as an interstate move regardless.
Ranked by net contribution, the picture reverses. New York sent 18,300 people and took back 5,700 for a net gain of about 12,600. Florida produced a net gain of 8,700. Illinois produced 5,900 on a flow of 6,600 in and fewer than 700 back, a ratio of nearly ten to one. Pennsylvania added 3,700 and New Jersey 2,600, the latter despite not appearing among the ten largest senders at all.
Grouped by region, the Northeast delivered about 22,300 net new residents, roughly four of every ten the state gained. The South contributed 12,900, the Midwest 12,000 and the West 7,600.
Military rotation explains part of the churn in the other direction. South Carolina hosts Fort Jackson, Shaw Air Force Base, Joint Base Charleston and the recruit depot at Parris Island. Virginia hosts Naval Station Norfolk. In 2024, about 140 people moved from Alaska to South Carolina while nearly 2,000 went the other way. That is not a housing preference. It is a set of orders.
The retiree flow is more durable. Data from the moving platform HireAHelper showed South Carolina with the largest net gain of movers age 65 and older of any state, about 5,400, drawn from roughly 14,000 older arrivals, more than one in eight of them from Florida. Florida itself netted only about 815 retirees. A research economist at the University of South Carolina's Moore School of Business told Realtor.com that some newcomers stop in Florida first, citing insurance costs that climbed sharply over the past decade and fewer extreme weather events in South Carolina.
Ten counties account for more than 80 percent of the state's population gain since the 2020 census. The rest of South Carolina is flat or shrinking.
Horry County added 13,244 residents, the largest numeric gain in the state and grew 3.2 percent. Berkeley grew 3.3 percent, Spartanburg 3.0 percent, Lancaster 2.7 percent. Jasper, at 6 percent, was the fastest growing county in America.
Lexington County grew 1.1 percent and Richland County 1.0 percent, ranking 17th and 18th of the state's 46 counties by rate. Since 2020, Richland has grown 4.5 percent against a statewide figure of 8.8 percent. Lexington has grown 8.1 percent, essentially at the state average.
This is the finding that unsettles the most common piece of advice about the state. Columbia and the surrounding Midlands are consistently described as the affordable alternative to the coast, a place where an established economic base supports long term demand. The base is real. Prisma Health Richland has operated as a trauma center since 1892 and anchors the region's medical employment. Lexington Medical Center covers the western side of the metro. The University of South Carolina enrolled about 41,650 students this fall. State government provides a floor.
But the low price is not a discovery waiting to be acted on. It is the price of weak demand. The demand has been weak for reasons that have not changed. Fort Jackson trains roughly half of all soldiers entering the Army each year, a throughput asset whose trainees rotate through in weeks and buy nothing. The Scout Motors plant in Blythewood, a $2 billion investment announced with up to 4,000 jobs, has not delivered a vehicle and does not expect to until 2028.
The honest case for the Midlands is stability rather than growth. It is the low volatility play in a state where the high growth counties carry the most risk.
Horry County demonstrates the distinction better than any other place in South Carolina. It is the fastest growing large county in the state and the weakest housing market in it. In the first half of 2026, the typical Myrtle Beach area home took about 111 days to sell, supply exceeded six months and only about 7 percent of homes sold above the original list price against roughly 21 percent nationally. Columbia, over the same period, ran about 52 days on market and three and a half months of supply. By autumn, Myrtle Beach had tightened to somewhere between 79 and 89 days, still far slower than the capital.
Median sale prices in the first half of 2026 were about $285,000 in Columbia, $333,000 in Greenville, $343,000 in Myrtle Beach and $453,000 in Charleston.
The Myrtle Beach city manager has described the bind plainly in local coverage. The people arriving are retirees who require services and the county struggles to hire the labor to provide them, because the workers cannot afford to live there. Retirees consume public services and supply no workforce. Growth without a workforce is a fiscal obligation wearing the costume of a boom.
Insurance completes the picture. Homeowners premiums in Myrtle Beach run about $445 a month, the highest in the state. That is more than $5,300 a year before a mortgage payment. A discount on the purchase price can be erased by the insurance line within three years.
The survey records where someone lived twelve months ago. It does not record why they left, whether they intend to stay, or whether the address was a dormitory, a barracks or a winter rental. It also describes 2024, and nearly two years have passed since.
Those two years moved the numbers. Domestic migration into South Carolina fell by roughly 12,000 between the 2025 and 2026 estimate releases. International migration fell by about 9,500. Nationwide, close to eight in ten counties that had grown in the prior year saw growth slow or reverse. South Carolina led the country in percentage growth partly because almost everywhere else slowed more.
The tax argument that drives much of the border movement is weaker than the folklore. South Carolina moved to a two rate structure for the 2026 tax year, 1.99 percent on the first $30,000 of taxable income and 5.21 percent above it. North Carolina charges a flat 3.99 percent in 2026, falling to 3.49 percent the following year. On $80,000 of taxable income the two bills land within about $10 of each other. South Carolina's advantage concentrates in retirement deductions, a $15,000 income deduction for residents 65 and older and a homestead exemption on the first $50,000 of market value.
The state is growing. It is not growing the way the headlines say, from the places the headlines name, or for the reasons most buyers assume. Four in ten net new residents come from the Northeast, most of the visible traffic across the southern border is people changing school districts. The cheapest housing market in South Carolina is cheap because the demand never arrived.
That is not an argument against moving there. It is an argument against paying for a boom that the data describes as a swap.
Sources:
State to state migration flows, 2024 (the ACS tables the analysis rests on) https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/geographic-mobility/state-to-state-migration.html
Vintage 2025 state population estimates, full data file (population, births, deaths, natural change, international and domestic migration by state) https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/popest/datasets/2020-2025/state/totals/NST-EST2025-ALLDATA.csv
Census press release, January 2026 (South Carolina as fastest growing state, 79,958 numeric growth, 66,622 net domestic, 1.5 percent) https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2026/population-growth-slows.html
Census QuickFacts, South Carolina (5,570,274 as of July 2025) https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/SC
Census QuickFacts, Lexington County (317,588, 8.1 percent since 2020) https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/lexingtoncountysouthcarolina
USA Facts, state to state migration for South Carolina (the 189,300 / 134,700 / 54,700 figures, the ten largest senders, and the New York net gain of 12,600) https://usafacts.org/answers/what-states-are-people-moving-to-and-from/state/south-carolina/
USA Facts, population change (county growth rates, Jasper at 6 percent, Horry leading numeric gain) https://usafacts.org/answers/is-the-population-growing-or-shrinking/state/south-carolina/
FRED, annual county population for South Carolina (every county, 2025 estimates) https://fred.stlouisfed.org/release/tables?eid=165358&rid=119
South Carolina Department of Employment and Workforce (1.5 percent growth, births exceeding deaths by 564, international migration falling to about 13,000 from 32,760) https://www.dew.sc.gov/index.php/labor-market-information-blog/2026-02/south-carolina-records-fastest-population-growth-country
Same agency, Jasper County (6 percent growth, fastest in the country, 2,195 added) https://dew.sc.gov/labor-market-information-blog/2026-05/jasper-county-records-fastest-population-growth-country
Post and Courier, statewide county breakdown (ten counties above 80 percent of growth, Horry at 427,551, Berkeley, Spartanburg, Lancaster, Jasper, the Myrtle Beach city manager quote, migration slowing by 12,000 domestic and 9,500 international) https://www.postandcourier.com/news/south-carolina-census-growth-development-population/article_261cf286-53e2-4d3e-a0ad-6511b99ea346.html
Post and Courier, Midlands counties (Richland 434,956 and 4.5 percent since 2020, Lexington 317,588 and 8.1 percent, rankings of 18th and 17th by rate) https://www.postandcourier.com/columbia/news/census-population-data-lexington-richland-midlands-sc/article_ab8a258b-8fb1-4a50-a4c9-5debb96098e8.html
Post and Courier, regional price comparison (Lowcountry about $425,000, Myrtle Beach about $325,000, Columbia about $274,000, Upstate about $313,000) https://www.postandcourier.com/newcomers-find-choice-and-value-across-south-carolina/article_aca895cd-efa8-43f8-bf38-09fb614fec83.html
Realtor.com, national migration piece (confirms the 189,282 national figure and the 18 percent North Carolina share) https://www.realtor.com/news/trends/net-domestic-migration-state-data-census-2025/
Realtor.com, Myrtle Beach market report, October 2026 (median list $319,900, 79 days on market, 20 percent of listings with price cuts) https://www.realtor.com/news/local/myrtle-beach-sc/real-estate-market-myrtle-beach-sc-october-2026/
Realtor.com, Myrtle Beach local market page (88 days median, 4,127 active listings, buyer's market, 97 percent sale to list ratio) https://www.realtor.com/local/market/south-carolina/horry-county/myrtle-beach
Redfin, Myrtle Beach (median sale $284,802, 89 days, up 15.1 percent) https://www.redfin.com/city/12572/SC/Myrtle-Beach/housing-market
Redfin, Columbia (median sale $275,328, 45 days, up 5.9 percent, 28 percent below national) https://www.redfin.com/city/4149/SC/Columbia/housing-market
FRED, Myrtle Beach days on market series (82 in August 2026, monthly history back to 2016) https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEDDAYONMAR34820
Zillow, Columbia home values ($229,923 typical value, 0.6 percent annual change, pending in about 32 days) https://www.zillow.com/home-values/4174/columbia-sc/
Property Pundit, statewide housing (state median $348,549, 74 days, Charleston $649,570, Greenville $514,659, Columbia $278,815, Myrtle Beach $262,326, plus the $445 monthly insurance figure) https://www.propertypundit.com/states/south-carolina
Restar, metro medians (Charleston metro $443,980, Myrtle Beach metro $349,709, Greenville metro $345,105, Columbia metro $279,358) https://restar.io/metrics/median-sale-price/by-state/sc
Resideline, closings tracked by market (Charleston $615,013, Myrtle Beach $266,465, Columbia $265,000) https://resideline.com/blog/south-carolina-housing-market
Coastal Carolinas MLS data (median sold $307,500, 6.3 months supply, 87 days, 97 percent of last list price) https://joefosterjr.com/myrtle-beach
America's Dashboard, IRS household flows (99.8K households in, 70.6K out, plus average AGI by origin state: New Jersey $106K, Virginia $103K, Pennsylvania $98K, New York $94K, North Carolina $84K, Florida $73K) https://americadashboard.com/migration/south-carolina
Stacker, older ACS breakdown (useful for the 2022 baseline showing how the sending mix shifted) https://stacker.com/stories/south-carolina/states-sending-most-people-south-carolina
US News, city comparisons (median home values for Greenville, Charleston and Columbia) https://realestate.usnews.com/places/rankings/best-places-to-live-in-south-carolina
The South Carolina Migration Paradox Nobody's Talking About
No comments:
Post a Comment