How American Progressives Influenced Hitler

The historical connection between American progressivism, particularly its advocacy for eugenics, and the ideologies that contributed to Nazi Germany under Adolf Hitler. It argues that progressivism, despite attempts to obscure its negative legacy, has played a significant role in shaping harmful ideas that have led to social strife both in the U. S. and abroad.

1. Historical Context of Progressivism:

• Progressivism was associated with various harmful ideologies, including eugenics, which aimed at improving the human population through selective breeding.

• Notable figures like Justice Clarence Thomas criticized progressivism for fostering ideologies that led to tyrannical regimes like those of Hitler, Stalin, and Mao, a claim that has been disputed by modern critics.

2. Eugenics and Its Spread:

• Eugenics was a significant component of progressive thought in the early 20th century, endorsed by many intellectuals and academics.

• This ideology created societal divisions in the U. S. and facilitated harmful policies regarding immigration and human rights, particularly against immigrants deemed "biologically inferior. "

• Prominent progressive members supported eugenic policies, such as Charles Benedict Davenport and Harry H. Laughlin, who argued for restrictive immigration laws to maintain the "biological superiority" of certain populations.

3. Immigration Laws and Workforce Manipulation:

• The Immigration Act of 1924 restricted immigration based on national origin, favoring northern Europeans and aiming to exclude southern and eastern Europeans.

• Progressive economists developed policies like the minimum wage, arguing it would eliminate "unemployable" workers, which they viewed as a form of eugenics in the labor market.

4. Links to Nazi Ideology:

• Many progressives, while denying their influence on Nazi ideology, overlook that Hitler admired and adapted American eugenics practices to justify his regime's racism and anti-Semitism.

• Foundations like the Rockefeller and Carnegie institutions financially supported eugenics research and promoted these ideas internationally, including in Germany.

5. Modern Legacy of Progressive Ideas:

• The ideological remnants of early 20th-century progressivism persist in contemporary discussions about policies such as assisted suicide and abortion, often framed in ways that echo past eugenic sentiments.

• Critics argue that the foundation of modern progressive thought continues to ignore the dangerous implications of eugenics and its historical applications.

The legacy of American progressivism is complex and often troubling, particularly regarding its historical embrace of eugenics. This movement contributed significantly to harmful ideologies and policies that not only affected American society but also provided a framework for the Nazi regime's racial policies. Despite modern attempts to sanitize this history, the influence of early progressivism remains evident in contemporary debates surrounding social and economic policies. The article concludes that this history underscores the need for a serious examination of progressivism's impact on society throughout the years. 

https://mises.org/mises-wire/how-american-progressives-influenced-hitler