Birthright Citizenship is National Suicide

 Daniel Greenfield discusses the implications of birthright citizenship in the context of national security. He highlights the challenges posed by individuals born in the U. S. to foreign nationals, particularly focusing on leaders of drug cartels and terrorist organizations who retain their American citizenship.

1. Case of Cartel Leadership: The new leader of Mexico's Jalisco New Generation Cartel, Juan Carlos Valencia Gonzalez, is a U. S. citizen born in California. His American citizenship complicates efforts by U. S. authorities to target him due to legal restrictions around citizenship.

2. Legal Framework: Current laws limit the government's ability to revoke citizenship, even for individuals engaged in activities against U. S. interests. Greenfield cites historical legal precedents that have made denaturalization increasingly difficult, noting a shift initiated by the Supreme Court's interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment regarding citizenship.

3. Historical Context: Previously, U. S. citizenship was linked to concepts of loyalty and allegiance, allowing for denaturalization in cases of treason or allegiance to foreign powers. Greenfield argues that this principle has eroded under modern interpretations of citizenship, primarily due to judicial activism.

4. Invariant Citizenship Principles: The author stresses that citizenship should be a voluntary act reflecting allegiance, rather than an automatic result of being born in the country. He argues that the current understanding of birthright citizenship undermines this principle and puts the nation at risk.

5. Citizenship and Allegiance: Greenfield makes the point that a person’s allegiance to the nation can no longer be taken for granted. He calls for a return to a system where citizenship is conditional upon an individual's ongoing loyalty to the U. S.

6. Potential Reforms: He suggests that the Trump administration and a more conservative Supreme Court may re-evaluate denaturalization laws. The focus should be on making the process of acquiring and maintaining citizenship more rigorous, emphasizing that citizenship should be earned rather than guaranteed by birthplace.

7. Crisis of Loyalty: Greenfield identifies a significant issue in the context of immigration policies leading to individuals holding citizenship without a corresponding allegiance to the United States. He points out that this creates vulnerabilities, particularly with individuals who may support terrorist activities against the country.

Greenfield advocates for a re-examination of birthright citizenship and the conditions under which citizenship is granted. He contends that without a meaningful connection between citizenship and allegiance, the integrity and safety of the nation will be compromised. Strengthening the ties between citizenship and loyalty is presented as essential for America's future stability. 

https://www.frontpagemag.com/birthright-citizenship-is-national-suicide/