The GOP Is About to Relive Its Worst Immigration Failure

 The Republican Party is grappling with a significant immigration issue, particularly regarding how to handle illegal immigration and deportations. This dilemma threatens to repeat past mistakes affiliated with immigration policy.

• Definitional Crisis: Republicans are struggling with how to define who should be deported, focusing on the "worst of the worst," which dilutes their campaign promises regarding mass deportation.

• Historical Context: Past Republican responses to immigration crises, like Romney's 2012 campaign failure, led to misleading narratives that claimed the current immigration status was beneficial or that mass deportation would be politically dangerous.

• Nature of the Crisis: The article argues that illegal immigration is a quantity issue rather than solely a quality problem linked to crime; high volumes of illegal immigrants impact wages, public services, and national unity.

• Political Messaging: There is concern that shifting the focus to only serious criminals marginalizes the broader issues and grievances of American communities affected by immigration.

• Contrast with Trump: Donald Trump’s approach focused on strong enforcement messages, such as "Build the Wall," which resonated with voters who felt past compromises were insufficient.

• Critique of ‘Autopsy’ Logic: The autopsy report suggested that Republicans soften their stance on immigration to appeal to Hispanic voters, which has been proven ineffective.

• Call to Action: Republicans are urged to avoid repeating previous mistakes by adhering to strong immigration enforcement and preventing limited deportation discussions from becoming the new norm.

As the GOP navigates the immigration debate, it must address and rectify past missteps to ensure that broader concerns of illegal immigration are adequately addressed, prioritizing firm enforcement over compromised positions. The future of America’s immigration policy and national identity is at stake. 

https://www.theamericanconservative.com/the-gop-is-about-to-relive-its-worst-immigration-failure/