The Myth of Virtuous Democracy

 Jim Cardoza argues that democracy is not inherently moral or virtuous. Instead, its value depends on how it is used. The piece highlights historical instances where democratic processes led to unjust outcomes.

• Democracy as a Tool: Democracy is merely a method for decision-making and has no moral content on its own. It can yield unjust results, such as segregation and wars, when used improperly.

• Distinction Between Democracy and Liberty: Democracy answers "who decides? " while liberty addresses "what should not be decided at all? " True rights should protect individuals from majority rule, not depend on popular approval.

• American Constitutional Order: The Founding Fathers designed the U. S. system as a constitutional republic, limiting majority power through laws and principles to protect individual rights. Elections were meant to choose leaders, not to define rights.

• Erosion of Restraints: The modern perception equating democracy with virtue undermines protections against majority oppression. Issues become framed in terms of public will, allowing for the infringement of rights.

• Risks of Unrestricted Democracy: Policies once seen as coercive become justified as democratic, and dissenters are labeled as opponents of democracy. Yet, the true test of freedom is how well it protects the rights of unpopular individuals.

• Role of Liberty: Liberty ensures security in life and property regardless of popular opinion, which is necessary for effective self-governance. Democracy should enhance, not replace, individual freedoms.

• Balanced Democracy and Liberty: While voting is important for peaceful governance, it is not intrinsically moral. America's greatness lies not in majority rule but in the idea that certain actions should remain beyond majority control.

The article emphasizes the need to maintain principles that constrain democracy to preserve liberty. History shows that unregulated democracy can undermine freedoms and lead to oppression, and rights cannot be subject to majority approval. The real choice is between democracy supported by principles and democracy unchecked by them. 

https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2026/01/the_myth_of_virtuous_democracy.html