How the FBI Lost Its Way

Former FBI Special Agent Pat McMonigle expresses deep concern about the agency's current operations and effectiveness. He highlights a troubling case of missed opportunities and failures within the FBI and law enforcement, calling for vital reforms to redirect the agency's mission.

1. Personal Experience: McMonigle recounts a tense encounter where FBI agents visited his home, seemingly to address his involvement in a media investigation revealing the Bureau's shortcomings.

2. Case of “764”: This case dealt with a horrific child-abuse network, where the FBI and German police failed to act on crucial information about a suspect, leading to tragic outcomes. The case serves as a clear indicator of the inefficiencies and failures within law enforcement partnerships.

3. Agency Transformation: Over the years, McMonigle observed that the FBI has shifted from a proactive agency to one burdened by bureaucracy and aversion to risk. Management often contradicts those who are deeply knowledgeable about cases, leading to a decline in operational effectiveness.

4. Morale Issues: Many FBI agents feel underpaid, overworked, and demoralized. Senior agents look forward to retirement, while new recruits struggle with low salaries in high-cost living areas.

5. Call for Reforms: McMonigle proposes three key reforms:

• Reconnect Leadership with Agents: The Bureau's leadership should actively support and engage with field agents.

• Emphasize Agent Expertise: The focus should return to agents and their operations rather than excessive oversight from bureaucrats and political appointees.

• Restore Core Mission: The FBI must prioritize protecting the public and enforcing the law over self-preservation and political concerns.

6. Ongoing Success Despite Issues: While the FBI continues to combat significant crimes, these successes occur in spite of, rather than because of, current leadership practices and operational dysfunction.

The FBI has strayed from its essential mission as McMonigle argues for a return to its roots of effective law enforcement, emphasizing the need for structural reform and a renewed focus on protecting vulnerable populations to avoid future tragedies. He concludes with a warning about the potential consequences if the Bureau does not change its course. 

https://www.city-journal.org/article/fbi-agents-leadership-intelligence-crime-white-tiger