Russ Gonnering discusses the problematic incentives driving the U. S. healthcare system. He cites the idea popularized by Donald Berwick that "Every system is perfectly designed for the results it gets," highlighting the gap in understanding complex healthcare issues among experts. Gonnering draws upon his experiences in medical quality improvement and illustrates how misconceptions in healthcare lead to poor outcomes.
1. Understanding Incentives:
• Incentives play a crucial role in any system, including healthcare. Experts often overlook how incentives shape behaviors and results.
• Gonnering reflects on his past misconceptions and realizations that many healthcare professionals do not fully grasp the differences between merely complicated and truly complex systems.
2. Complex Adaptive Systems:
• Healthcare is a Complex Adaptive System where multiple factors interact in unpredictable ways.
• Traditional approaches focusing on statistical quality control fail for complex problems because such problems require a different toolset.
• Predictability within complex systems is limited; practitioners must adapt continuously.
3. Embracing Small Failures:
• To navigate complex problems, it’s essential to accept and learn from small failures rather than striving for a perfect solution from the outset.
• The process of “constructively changing course” is vital for successful outcomes.
4. Challenges in Implementing Change:
• Influencing change in the healthcare sector is difficult, especially among established professionals.
• Many institutions resist evolving due to fear of losing status or job security, which hinders progress.
5. Organizational Culture:
• Organizational culture significantly influences performance. Gonnering references research indicating that most professionals remain at a underdeveloped stage of organizational culture (Stage 3).
• The current culture often stifles cooperation and creative problem-solving.
6. Shift in Medical Focus:
• The shift towards cosmetic procedures in medicine reflects a larger trend driven by financial incentives, often at the expense of altruistic practices.
• Issues in reimbursement and liability discourage focusing on patients in need of essential care.
7. Core Motivations:
• According to Dan Pink, key motivators in any profession—especially healthcare—are autonomy, mastery, and purpose. Current healthcare systems have largely stripped these elements away, resulting in low morale.
8. Need for Reform in Education:
• Educational reform is critical to address the deep-seated problems.
• A focus on developing critical thinking, leadership, and ethics in healthcare education should start well before professional training.
9. Community of Practice:
• Building networks of support among healthcare professionals is essential for fostering resilience.
• Initiatives should include creating opportunities to engage with and bolster this community.
10. Addressing Systemic Issues:
• A complex problem like the current state of U. S. healthcare lacks simple solutions; it requires consistent application of complexity tools to navigate effectively.
• Pilot projects and adaptive methods tailored to local needs should be explored to identify effective practices.
Gonnering stresses the urgent need to reform the healthcare system by addressing its complex nature and erroneous incentivization structures. This requires a cultural shift towards valuing critical skills and creating a supportive community among health professionals. Immediate action is needed to initiate this process, revising both training and organizational practices to foster a healthcare environment that encourages the right motivations and values.
https://brownstone.org/articles/the-perverse-incentives-in-the-us-healthcare-system/
No comments:
Post a Comment