The article discusses how modern media distorts truth, especially regarding public figures like Donald Trump. The author, Roger Kimball, compares today's journalism to ancient rhetorical practices described by Quintilian, suggesting a manipulation of facts and bias.
1. Media Distortion: The media, particularly outlets like The New York Times, misrepresents facts about individuals (e. g. , Elon Musk) to weave a narrative that aligns with their biases. The article emphasizes the flawed portrayal of Musk’s South African background.
2. Critique of CNN's Stephen Collinson: Kimball criticizes Collinson’s view of Trump as a dictator attacking elites. He argues that Trump's actions are legitimate and supported by his electoral mandate for changes such as immigration reform and fiscal responsibility.
3. Misinterpretation of Intent: The author counters Collinson's assertions that Trump seeks retribution against political enemies. Kimball claims Trump intends to address abuses by bureaucratic systems rather than enacting revenge.
4. Distorted Terminology: The term "elite" is used incorrectly to label Trump’s opponents. Kimball argues that being "elite" refers to credentialed status rather than actual merit or achievement.
5. Anti-Semitism and Campus Reform: Kimball highlights Collinson's failure to acknowledge anti-Semitism in Trump’s education policies, arguing that the measures taken were aimed at promoting accountability and traditional values in education.
6. Overall Message: Kimball portrays Collinson’s rhetoric as deceptive and steeped in anti-Trump sentiment. He suggests that the media constructs narratives that vilify Trump while ignoring legitimate concerns about responsibility and governance.
The article presents a scathing critique of modern journalism, particularly its treatment of Donald Trump and others. It emphasizes the need for critical reading to discern truth from politicized messaging, arguing that the current media landscape distorts reality and undermines honest discourse.
Comments
Post a Comment