Thursday, September 29, 2022

US Constitution Article V Convention

 The Convention of States has no power to rewrite the constitution, or even to amend the constitution

  • It only may propose amendments, just as Congress can
  • 38 states must ratify each proposed amendment
  • The convention of states cannot propose amendments to any issue it wants
  • Previous attempts at calling Article V conventions have resulted in SCOTUS precedents stating that all amendments are limited to the subjects of a convention's petition
  • SCOTUS precedent has already established that each state delegation has one vote
  • This is a situation where there is potential risk, but also potential benefit. The challenge being to minimize the risks and maximize the benefits

The Convention Process

  • JBS writer Christian Gomez disagrees with the vast majority of well-known conservative scholars who have weighed in on the issue, he agrees with respected, conservative constitutional experts on at least one thing about the Constitution: it is the bulwark of protection for liberty in America.
  • While the respected and widely published experts believe that Article V's convention process is an essential part of that bulwark, Gomez seems to believe it is some kind of self-destruct button.
  • On the other hand, arguing in favor of the states using the Article V convention process, we have nationally renowned constitutional experts with too many letters behind their name to list here.

https://rwmalonemd.substack.com/p/us-constitution-article-v-convention?utm_source=post-email-title&publication_id=583200&post_id=75643843&isFreemail=true&utm_medium=email

No comments:

Post a Comment

Blue State Failure Is Destroying Federalism And The Constitution

 The ongoing crisis of animal abuse in Los Angeles, highlighting the failure of local authorities to address the problem. As the situation w...